Tucked within the artsy Water Street Market, Mudd Puddle is New Paltz’s quintessential independent coffee roaster and café. The vibe is cozy-bohemian – colorful mugs, local art on the walls, and always a mix of students, tourists, and townsfolk chatting or reading. They roast their own coffee in small batches, ensuring each cup (from drip brews to lattes) is fresh and flavorful. Menu favorites include the maple latte, cold-brew iced coffee, and an assortment of loose-leaf teas. To eat, Mudd Puddle offers freshly baked pastries, bagels with house spreads, quiches, and sandwiches (with vegan options too). With outdoor seating overlooking the market courtyard and occasional live music, the café invites you to linger and soak up the New Paltz community spirit one cup at a time.